#7 Frosty the Dumbman
Reed Harris asked Kaitlin Whipple to marry him in a Wendy’s, so strike one. Then he hid the ring in her Frosty milkshake, so strike two. Then he invited her and her friends to chug down the chilling beverage and she — yup — swallowed the ring. Did the ring eventually “turn up”? Yes. The two are set to get married. Who knows why.